Tags
Amelia Earhart, aviation, beauty, bravery, breast implants, Charles Lindbergh, Cosmopolitan, courage, freckles, insecurities, insecurity, losing weight, outward appearance, overweight, wrinkles
I’ve always looked up to Amelia Earhart. She was an adventurer, an innovator and an entrepreneur. She changed the aviation industry forever and inspired generations of women to go after their dreams. And she had a boatload planeload of spunk to boot.
So you can imagine my surprise when I recently found out that she didn’t like the way she looked.
What? How could this be possible? That precious pixie cut, that contagious smile, how she looked in that adorable bomber hat… How could this girl ever think she was ugly?
Maybe we should start at the beginning.
Earhart was born in Kansas but quickly realized that her true home was in the clouds. A daredevil, Earhart is remembered for her groundbreaking feats of aviation, most notably being the first woman to fly across the Atlantic Ocean alone. Her courage lifted the spirits of Americans — even during the Great Depression — as she set aviation records in altitude, distance and endurance.
But it was her last flight that she might be most known for — a flight that tragically never arrived at its intended destination. At age 39, Earhart set out to be the first person to circle the globe, taking off from California with her navigator. They made it all the way to New Guinea, completing some 27,000 miles. But then the unthinkable happened: Her plane disappeared. Investigators believe that it went down near a group of small, uninhabited islands in the remote South Pacific. A massive search was triggered to no avail.

Earhart made headlines again recently — 75 years after that fateful day — after excavations of the island have turned up clues that she may have landed safely and inhabited the island as a castaway. Found on the island were several products believed to be manufactured in the U.S. in the 1930s. They include: a woman’s compact, a flight jacket zipper, a jar that may have once contained Dr. C.H. Berry’s Freckle Ointment, and one green bottle that was possibly St. Joseph’s Liniment used for first aid and mosquito repellent. Investigators believe that “the abundance of cosmetics and beauty products on the desert island provides further circumstantial evidence for the presence of an American woman.”
I’m so intrigued by this stuff! I could read for hours about Earhart’s life, differing theories of what happened to her, and even the outlandish propagandist theories. (No, I don’t believe Earhart was spying on the Japanese for FDR when she was taken hostage and executed.)
Now investigators are setting out on a new expedition to find Earhart’s doomed plane, armed with new, deep water submersibles and side scanning sonar technology. Should they find the wreckage, they will be one step closer to solving one of the greatest aviation mysteries of all time.
In reading all the new press surrounding this old mystery, I’m stuck on one (or many) points — Earhart’s freckles. That jar of freckle ointment found on the island was marketed in the early 20th century under the promise of making freckles fade.
“It’s well-documented Amelia had freckles and disliked having them,” said Joe Cerniglia, the International Group for Historic Aircraft Recovery (TIGHAR) researcher who spotted the freckle ointment as a possible match.

When I see Amelia Earhart, I see classic beauty. I see bravery. I see an entrepreneur and adventurer who changed the course of the aviation industry forever. But when she looked in the mirror, Amelia saw ugly freckles. I suppose it didn’t help that media outlets referred to her as “Lady Lindy” because of her physical resemblance to fellow aviator Charles “Lucky Lindy” Lindbergh. Being told you look like a man can’t be great for your self esteem.
But Amelia isn’t alone in her insecurities. Why do we women do this? Why do we second guess ourselves based on how we look, based on things we presume to be flaws? I hate that Amelia felt the need to change the way she looked. I hate that her freckles made her feel less than beautiful.
But what about me? I’m working hard in my career, faithfully blogging, writing my first novel. I’m a dedicated friend, a loyal daughter, sister and aunt. But what do I see when I look in the mirror? Do I see my bravery, my courage? Do I see my talent or my spunk? Or do I just see the metaphorical freckles spattered over my skin? Freckles can manifest themselves in different ways for different people: overweight, a big nose, crooked teeth, frizzy hair, blotchy skin, wrinkles, a flat chest, wide hips. And sadly, the grass isn’t always greener: underweight, a small nose, yellow teeth, flat hair, pale skin, pimples, huge breasts, no curves.
As much as I want to grab Amelia Earhart by the shoulders and shake her, I should probably be doing the same to myself. Perhaps I should be proud of Amelia for succeeding so much in spite of her insecurities — the same insecurities we all have.
Funny thing — among many other accomplishments, Earhart was a successful writer and author who served as aviation editor for Cosmopolitan magazine for two years. If Earhart could see what happened to the magazine over the last century, I wonder if she’d be saddened. I wonder if she’d hate the emphasis on outward beauty being shoved down our throats every day. And I wonder if she’d burn her freckle ointment and write an article about it in protest.
Because that’s the Amelia Earhart I believe existed underneath it all, complete with adorable freckles, a bit of an attitude and an amazing two-story tree house where she and her navigator and new love lived happily until the day they both died of old age. (Just my personal theory.)
On beauty, Amelia Earhart said it best in her own words… though she may not have known it at the time:
The stars seemed near enough to touch and never before have I seen so many. I always believed the lure of flying is the lure of beauty, but I was sure of it that night.
~Ruth
heysheila said:
I was with a friend yesterday who was lamenting about how flabby her stomach is (she is a mother and her flabby tummy gave birth to a perfect little boy), and saying that she needs to work out more and how she can see her stomach through her shirt. She was talking down about herself…to herself. That can’t be good for her self esteem.
This friend is a good 8 inches taller than me and probably 90 pounds lighter. I look at myself in the mirror and see that I am overweight but I do not look in the mirror and say to myself “you’re fat”. I do color my hair and use face cream (both since I was 25), and I would hope that I would have a positive view of myself even if I wasn’t coloring my hair. But I think being proactive is a good thing, that’s what I think Amelia was doing with the freckle cream (it probably had a spf of 70), and I’m not sure if she would have burned it in protest of the direction Cosmopolitan went because using that cream probably made her feel good.
And feeling good about yourself is half the battle.
Ruth Rutherford said:
I hear ya. To put this into perspective, I don’t think by any means that we shouldn’t do anything to better our appearance. If you saw my medicine cabinet and make-up bag, you’d call me a big hypocrite! I’m all about lotions and potions and cover-ups. They definitely make me feel better and help me take care of myself.
I just found the contradiction powerful. Amelia was such a strong, successful woman… but still struggled with insecurity about her looks. WOW. I would like to think that I’m so secure that I don’t care if I have wrinkles or if I’m overweight… but it’s not true. So, I’m just trying to find the balance of putting that stuff into perspective.
As for your friend… so sad. I hope she can realize that life is about the ebb and flow. Yes, she weighs more now than she once did, but she also has an amazing child that she never had. The joy is worth it all… and, in time, she can work toward losing the weight.
Thanks for reading and commenting!
heysheila said:
I get what you’re saying, absolutely. The contradiction is, as you say, powerful.
This makes me think of Oprah. Super powerful and openly discussed her struggle with weight on national television.
I love reading your well written opinions. Keep ‘em coming and I’ll keep reading!
Elise said:
Great post, Ruth! And good food for thought. I too sometimes find the worst in me to complain about instead of all the good there is. Thank you for the reminder and the post! I love your writing! :c)
Ruth Rutherford said:
Thanks, Elise! Glad I could remind you of something so important… especially since I’m reminding myself every day, too!
26datesin2012 said:
It’s interesting that there are so many posts about our perception of ourselves and judging ourselves are popping up these days. This one goes along similar lines: http://yogawithnadine.com/2012/07/16/comparing-yourself-its-a-trap/
Great writing once more.
Wandering Voiceless said:
I *just* had this same conversation with a friend a few weeks ago. We were at a family reunion picnic, and we were both avoiding being in pictures like the plague. I mean, seriously. Why not just enjoy ourselves and get in the damn picture with a huge smile on our face!
I bounce back and forth between an “I don’t care” acceptance (of my weight), and “I need to care” because bad things are happening (health wise).
I think all of us are a mish-mash of insecure and confident, and I think we build up our confidence in certain areas, so that we can tamper our insecurity in others.
Human nature, eh?
Thanks as always for a great, great post. Good research. Nice writing. Well done. :>
Marilyn said:
i so enjoyed this post. For one, I too am intrigued but Amelia Earhart (as well as D.B. Cooper *smile*) This was a good reminder that I need to be content even though I tend to fret over my weight way too often. I do have lots of freckles but I kinda like them.
Ruth Rutherford said:
I love freckles! I don’t have any (have darker, olive-y skin)… but always wanted them. I think they’re precious, especially after a day in the sun! I always wanted to be Annie growing up…
I’m ALSO intrigued by the DB Cooper mystery! You and I will definitely have plenty to chat about over coffee one day…
Marilyn said:
I totally agree!! One day when I’m visiting DC, I will have to look you up and have that coffee chat.
Ruth Rutherford said:
Absolutely!
Kadeen said:
This was a great post! I’m finally getting to catch up with everyone again
I love my freckles, though being brown skinned and all I never expected to see any
but the age old burr under my blanket is the hair on my arms and legs X_X. I yoyo back and forth between acceptance and finding a way to permanently rid myself of the little buggers
but the fact remains that everyone has a perceived blemish, and the best way to look at is to find your good points and remind yourself that self perceived blemishes do not have to define our outlook on life negatively.